Skip to content

Piece of Cake

While I finish up the Portland writeups (I haven’t even gotten to Lucas yet, it’s already old news, and I’m about to go on yet another trip!), I’d like to share with you a little ditty I made for a friend’s birthday. I had planned on baking him a cake, and when he replied that he liked carrot cake, went to look up recipes. During this process I realized that 1) carrot cake is complicated and 2) I suck at baking, who am I kidding?

So I decided to knit him one instead:

carrot cake

All the frosting and none of the calories.

As a bonus, this time I actually thought to jot down coherent pattern notes as I was making the thing! (Well, if I posted a picture of what I actually scribbled, it would look like moon-writing to most people. But I understand what I wrote. I think.)

Carrot Cake Pattern – easy, scrumptious, and adaptable to other types of cake as well. Just change the colors!

2 balls heavy worsted weight yarn – 1 in a frosting-ish color, 1 in a carrot cake color (orange with speckles works nicely to convey the carroty texture).
Size 8 needles
Tapestry needle
Filling – I used a combination of stiff pillow form and soft polyfill.
Some felt for the “marzipan” carrot embellishment (alternately you could knit this too, but I chose not to because I was working against a deadline!)

I assembled the carrot cake thusly:
carrot cake

Anatomy of a carrot cake.

carrot cake

Pardon the crudeness of these drawings.

Instructions for the layer part (note, the bottom layer is knit first):

1. CO 28 sts in cake color.
2. Knit in stockinette (knit first row, purl the next, alternating rows) for 8 rows.
3. Knit 2 rows in frosting color.
4. Knit 6 rows in cake color.
5. Knit 4 rows in frosting color. Bind off, leaving a long tail of yarn.

That was easy enough, right? Now, on to the frosting part:

1. CO 12 sts in frosting color.
2. Knit in stockinette for 20 rows.
3. K2tog, k until last two stitches, k2tog. (10 sts)
4. Knit in stockinette for 3 rows.
5. Repeat steps 3 and 4 until you have two stitches left. Knit one more row and bind off, leaving a long tail.
6. Turn the piece around, and making sure the right side is facing you, pick up 12 stitches on the other side.
7. Repeat steps 3 – 5 for this side.

Now, the piping – I did this with i-cord trickery:

1. CO 3 sts in frosting color.
2. Kfb all sts.
3. Knit 4 more rows in i-cord fashion (see knitting help for instructions; scroll down towards the bottom on that page).
4. K2tog all sts.
5. Repeat rows 2-4 until the length of the piping matches the width of the cake. Bind off, leaving a long tail, and sew the piping onto the cake. (Note: the pipettes (or scallops, or whatever you call them) didn’t turn out as emphasized as I’d like them, so I fixed that when I sewed the piece onto the rest of the cake.)

Now you can weave in all your ends, stitch the sucker together partially, and stuff. Then you can sew on a felt carrot (or rosette, or cherry – use your imagination!), and finish seaming the cake. Bon appetit!

carrot cake

Looks good, but do not try to eat this. Um. Just trust me.

3 people like this post.


  1. I love carrot cake! Very cute pattern! I’ll have to make a slice for my pa.

    I see in your little bio that your “porch-hollerer”. I like that. I’d holler from a porch if I had one, but alas, I have only a little walk-in entry….so I holler out my front window. *grin*

  2. Symantha Symantha

    wow thats really nifty. hehe i took a picture of it and showed it to all my friends and they thought it was so cute.

  3. Sab Sab

    I love that! I’d totally make it too… if I knew how to knit! Maybe I’ll have to learn…

    0 Calorie cake… = perfect!

  4. Tif Tif

    Awesome! I’m definitely making one (or two, or three…) :)


  5. […]   I was looking for a pattern to make a knitted cake as a gift and found a lovely easy one over at Bad Metaphor.  The pattern is simple and there is also a diagram to help with putting it all together.  I […]

  6. […] knitted cake Image by slideshow bob less calories and more colourful. Pattern here: […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *